First, I need to get something off my chest: MICROING HOWITZERS IS INCREDIBLY DEADY!!!
Alright, I feel better now :)
Very nicely done on both sides. I particularly liked (and am looking forward to doing myself from now on) how both players used "attack ground" with their artillery weapons, "leading" their targets. Some good hotkey work there :)
I gave the game 4 instead of 5 because of a bit of forgetfulness (on both sides) when it came to the economy. By that I mean leaving the TC idle for periods of time and sending woodcutters far away but not setting up a settlement (Shogun_X)
Oh one last thing: Smokescreening the howitzers instead of doughboys might have a more beneficial effect :)