Playability: 3
It was pretty easy to play all i had to do was time my attacks and airpower.
Balance: 2
The first one one was well balanced the second one was not because they had such strong weapons
Creativity: 3
I did like the creativity but taking over a hill how fun can it really be?
Map Design: 2
Nothing interesting a river some trees and hills basically it was blah!
Story/Instructions: 2
There were not very many clear instuctions all I new was to take over the hill but you were wrong it was not marked with a flag so I was kinda lost!
Additional Comments:
I am pleased considering this is your first scenario and that you could use some work with triggers but over all its not half bad :)