Empires Heaven
Welcome
Downloads Home
Review Guidelines
Main site
Forums
Code of Conduct
Search

Advanced Search
Campaigns
Home
New Releases
New Reviews
New Comments
Top-Rated

Submit File
Browse Categories
New Files

Downloads Home » Campaigns » Kursk - The Triumph of Combined Arms

Download File Post Review Post Comment

Kursk - The Triumph of Combined Arms

Author File Description
Talon Karrde
File Details
Style: Other
# of Scenarios: 1
Version: Empires: Retail Release
"Soviet successes in early 1943 and German counter-attacks had left a great bulge or salient round Kursk between Orel and Kharkov. Hitler had once postponed Operation Citadel, as the plan to pinch out the Kursk salient was known, and had considered a proposal by OKW to build up a strong reserve instead, but on 18 June he decided to proceed: Citadel would demonstrate German superiority by reversing the disasters at Stalingrad, and the stalemate on the front. The plan did indeed demonstrate German strength, with 900,000 men, 2700 tanks and assault guns and 1800 aircraft massed for the attack, although this was achieved by concentrating 70% of German tanks and 65% of the aircraft from the entire Eastern Front.
"Although often thought of as a tank battle, Kursk as a whole arguably demonstrated the triumph of artillery, infantry and engineers over armour. The Soviet plan was to soak up the German assault in a colossal web of defensive positions, and only then launch their armoured counter-attack. It was also an important air battle, in which the balance now shifted in favour of the Soviets."
--Collins' Atlas of the Second World War

Welcome to Kursk.
AuthorReviews   ( All | Comments Only | Reviews Only )
Field Marshal BM
Rating
4.4
Breakdown
Playability5.0
Balance5.0
Creativity4.0
Map Design4.0
Story/Instructions4.0
First off I wanna start out and congratulate you on completing this, I know the hard work that goes into any qaulity campaign/cinimatic, and in no way in the folowing reveiw am I trying to degrade your efforts etc, so hats off.


now on to the reveiw

1. Playibility: The cinimatic played almost flawlessly, the only thing is, it was a bit laggy because of all the troops on the map etc. but i know you could'nt help this to much and part of it was my computer so I'll let you off the hook ;)


2. balance: The balance of the scenario seemed pretty near perfect, I gave it a five because there's not to much to say about it in a cinimatic. And the scenario is based on actual (uneven?) odds I assume. So I don't expect you to change history :p I'd have more to say if it were a campaign/scenario etc.



3. Creativity: Now heres the thing Unfortunatly I had to give it a four, because it's not exactly the most origional thing out there, although you did a very good job on taking the circumstances and recreating them. I especialy liked the use of graphic effects etc in the artillary barrages, flamthrowers, and Mg's. Also the custom sounds were very nicely done, and it was alot better than having to read it. Although, the only complaint I have is that alot of the time I could not understand what he was saying because the custom noises drown the speaker out. Also, I saw when the load of conscripts was coming in that one scene, there was a make shift train in the backround, very nicely thought of. I would have liked to see some more of that in the cinimatic, because I got a little bored after awhile, seeing as it seemed to get kind of repetitive in the way it progressed. such as, tank comes down ally way, gets shot, sniper shoots soldiers etc. but It was still nicely done. just try and be more creative in the way you do the fights in the future.


4. Map design: Now, unfotunatly I had to nock this down one point (now keep in mind a four is still very good and in no way bad) because in the city's etc there was just that little bit of "oomph" missing. The ruins in the right spot etc. The plains were just a tad bit to plain too, Try putting in some hills and more grass, mix green grass with tan grass etc, put scrubs, you get the idea. I liked the entrenchments, but still, there was that little bit of somthing missing. so just try and put that extra bit in next time. But again, I'm only trying to help you out here. The campaign was very nicely done. Keep up the good work


5. Story/instructions: The story was a bit lacking I hafto say, the sound files of people speaking helped out alot, but since half the time they were drown out I could'nt realy tell to much what was going on. The main screen did'nt have to much info either. So try getting some more info maybe, give some more backround and tell (or let be heard :p) whats going on. But Since I pretty much knew what was going on most of the time I gave it a 4, nice job.





Well, I hafto say, it was a very nice cinimatic, well thought out with hours of hard work put into it, I applaud you for your hard work and determination on this porject. Next time perhaps try and take into acount the fields I have touched on, I just kind of got the feeling of getting a little bored throughout it through the proces of fighting. Oh and, try sprucing up your camera movments, they're a little bland. still good though, just try and make them more dinamic.


Overall, nice job ;)
RTEHistDesignll
Rating
4.6
Breakdown
Playability5.0
Balance5.0
Creativity4.0
Map Design4.0
Story/Instructions5.0
Additional comments to BM's review

1. Trenches were done very nicely.
2. Excellent sounds for the stuka dive bomber.
3. I disagree with BM's remarks regarding the terrain, I thought it was well mixed.
4. The spawning of conscripts from the barracks was a problem though as they seemed to appear out of thin air. Maybe spawning them from behind the building where we as the viewers could not see it would work, just a suggestion.
5. I also agree with BM's comments on the Russian commander speaking. It was a little long and somewhat choppy, but the cinematic itself did not lagg much for me.
6. One thing I noticed that I thought was ingenious was the fact that the Russian commander was addressing his battle plan to soldiers as well as citizens. Now I don't know if you meant to do this but it created a sense of urgency for the Russian people, that everyone was involved in the war effort for Russia, including common people. If the cinematic was not meant to be portrayed in this way then disregard. :)

Overall a great job, hard for me to criticize something that I cannot do.


Post Review Post Comment

HGDL v0.8.0

Login
Forum Username:


Password:




Create a new account
Forgot password?
Rating
4.5
Breakdown
Playability5.0
Balance5.0
Creativity4.0
Map Design4.0
Story/Instructions4.5
Statistics
Downloads:880
Favorites: [Who?]0
Size:6.89 MB
Added:01/29/05