You must be logged in to post messages.
Please login or register

Scenario Design Discussions
Moderated by GoSailing

Hop to:    
Welcome! You are not logged in. Please Login or Register.135 replies, Sticky
Empires Heaven » Forums » Scenario Design Discussions » Report Download Reviews/Comments Thread
Bottom
Topic Subject:Report Download Reviews/Comments Thread
« Previous Page  1 ··· 4 5 6  Next Page »
Park
Member
(id: Angel Park)
posted 01-20-04 02:50 PM EDT (US)         
EH is proud to be the home for many designers and fans in the community. Therefore, in hopes of maintaining a positive environment for all fans including the map makers, reviewers, and just the playing fans, this thread has been created.

This thread is only to be used to report comments and/or reviews in the EH Downloads that you believe should be looked at and possibly removed. All that I really need are names and a URLs.

These are the Guidelines written some time ago, somehow never made light of day. Reviews do not have to completely abide by these rules, but they're obvious limits as to what a review can and cannot be.
http://empires.heavengames.com/staff/park/review.shtml

I'll also try to keep track of removed/changed reviews:

Hans Müller
Majicman182
Too short of a review

II WORLD WAR TOTAL
Gold Dragon
No actual review, just scores

II WORLD WAR TOTAL
tonymalone
No actual review, just scores

Seven Objects
Jorgias
NO actual review again, just scores

Knights Vs Tanks
Jorgias

North vs South
Third Fleet
Changed review into comment

II WORLD WAR TOTAL
lindisima
Bad smurf Review

II WORLD WAR TOTAL
jontxu
Bad smurf Review

1/23/04
The Matrix
Gaurdian_112
No real details specific to the movie/scn, changed to comment

The Matrix
jontxu
Only scores and 3 words, changed to comment

Seven Objects
Solo_fighter
Too short review, changed to comment

1/26/04
Until More Information is Gathered, I'm no longer accepting Jorgias's scenarios and temp. removing ones currently on (3 of them). Seems to be a good chance of smurf reviews.

1/2004
Reginas reviews all turned into comments

1/30/2004
Solo Fighter's Review turned to comment
http://empires.heavengames.com/downloads/showfile.php?fileid=1926
Ranger Challenges
too short

Gaurdian's Review for Empires Demo turned to comment

World War
Are You Monkey Turned to Comment

Crossing the Volga
WarLord_ZeZar
Turned to comment

2/1
http://empires.heavengames.com/downloads/showfile.php?fileid=1897
World Wap 1.5v
guyver to comment

2/4
Crossing the Volga
Cheez_Thra, changd to comment

Capture Flags
Changed to comment

2/17
http://empires.heavengames.com/downloads/showfile.php?fileid=1876
Hans Müller
Empiresww2 to comment, didn't even finish the scenario/campaign

2/22
World War I (The German Invasion)
WarLord_Zezar

Hitman v1.0
WarLord_Shadow X
third_day_fan

Battle of Pellenor Fields
WarLord_Zezar

March - April
Various reviews marked down to comment, most of them had an additional comment by me put in anyway.

4/4
DDAY_By_mario2004
Robert
2 line review

4/4
Removed 2nd Bad Copy of Alex40045's The French and English war for Supremacy

4/4
Crossing the Volga
Removed USAWay's Review

4/8
File #2025, a recorded game copy submission, removed since 2024 is the exact same thing.

4/12
LOTR Battle for Minas Tirith
Changed to comment

4/21
Deleted over 80 useless comments by Dopple, one by one, ~5 clicks each and banned him

4/24
4 of jimbo6james' comments, 1 line useless stuff

4/25
stupidbeef1124's comment on d-day scenario mp, and warned email sent. Also, removed a 1 score on another person's D-day map.

7/17
Retracted 2 reviews for Hans Muller, way too short. This designer needs a real review if his work is really good.


Grex, Imhotep, Jaded Knights, Punks, University, Glows, Facility, Trade Center, Stainless Steel Studios.

Former Seraph & Angel
My Twitter, i.e. don't bother
Learning Korean Language
Free Rice

[This message has been edited by Angel Park (edited 07-17-2004 @ 01:11 PM).]

AuthorReplies:
Midgard Eagle
Member
posted 10-13-05 05:43 AM EDT (US)     126 / 135       
The snow mod

Link

Two one-paragraph "reviews".


Woad Creations veteran, WiC junkie
Park
Member
(id: Angel Park)
posted 10-19-05 08:41 PM EDT (US)     127 / 135       
*peeps in*

I don't think people should review demos, didn't I put that in the guidelines?

I left the reviews for the snow mod. Assuming it does what it says then it sounds like it deserves a 5.0, unless someone writes a real review then I'll remove the two.


Grex, Imhotep, Jaded Knights, Punks, University, Glows, Facility, Trade Center, Stainless Steel Studios.

Former Seraph & Angel
My Twitter, i.e. don't bother
Learning Korean Language
Free Rice
Intrepid
Member
posted 12-09-05 00:42 AM EDT (US)     128 / 135       
Intrepid
Member
posted 12-28-05 05:24 PM EDT (US)     129 / 135       
Blascapone
Member
posted 12-28-05 05:46 PM EDT (US)     130 / 135       
.
.
Sometimes, a bad review is the only one way that we have to know if a campaign/scenario/etc is or is not good. Ok, much of the bads reviews are made by people that is new in heavengames and sometimes have not seen a lot of scenarios yet and his reviews are not the more liked, but if in a file there are not other review, why remove the review? When other person write a better review, it would be the moment to remove the bad review.
It is what I think.
.
.

Projects released:
-The Battle for Madrid Spanish Civil War
-The Battle for The Hell Vietnam War
-The Battle for Stalingrad (Parts 1,2,3 and 4) WWII
Intrepid
Member
posted 12-28-05 06:33 PM EDT (US)     131 / 135       
Poorly written, short, or inflammatory reviews reflect poorly on heavengames; likewise, these reviews are not helpful to the creator themselves. A good review tells a scenario designer what they did well and what needs to be improved upon. The reviews I just cited were short, poorly written and completely devoid of content. Neither review would help the respective authors, nor would they inform site visitors about the quality of the projects, hence they should be removed.
Adder
Fallen Angel
(id: The Adder)
posted 12-29-05 12:12 PM EDT (US)     132 / 135       
Additionally, generally the review is just turned into a comment, so that the comment's still there - the actual ranking is not.

Adder |
"I would like to wonder if Adder always acts like a stuck up asshole?" - Coldviper
Adder
Fallen Angel
(id: The Adder)
posted 01-14-06 02:56 PM EDT (US)     133 / 135       
http://empires.heavengames.com/downloads/showfile.php?fileid=1927

jmsiona


Adder |
"I would like to wonder if Adder always acts like a stuck up asshole?" - Coldviper
Blascapone
Member
posted 01-14-06 04:02 PM EDT (US)     134 / 135       
.
http://empires.heavengames.com/downloads/showfile.php?fileid=2280
Toolboy

He thought that the campaign had a bug, and much of the sections was scored thinking that the bug existed, later he accepted that was not bug and said that would edit the review. The time past and he does not edit the review.
.


Projects released:
-The Battle for Madrid Spanish Civil War
-The Battle for The Hell Vietnam War
-The Battle for Stalingrad (Parts 1,2,3 and 4) WWII
Intrepid
Member
posted 01-14-06 04:33 PM EDT (US)     135 / 135       
Toolboy said that he would replay and re review your scenario ten days ago. I am not going to remove a review after such a short period of time, give Toolboy more time.
« Previous Page  1 ··· 4 5 6  Next Page »
You must be logged in to post messages.
Please login or register

Hop to:    

Empires Heaven | HeavenGames